(631) 306-4663 ryan@rezinas.com Signature Premier Properties
Traffic Dashboard
Home Home
  • Home
  • Buying
    • Buying Guide
    • Mortgage Calculator
  • Selling
    • Selling Guide
    • Home Valuation
    • See your Fire Island Escapes!
    • Recently Sold
  • Search
  • Featured Listings
  • Areas
  • About Us
    • About The Salt Shore Team
    • Meet The Team
    • Testimonials
    • Blog
    • Join Us
  • Contact
Traffic Dashboard
Ryan Rezinas
(631) 306-4663 ryan@rezinas.com
  • 95 main St
    Sayville, NY 11782
Home
  • Home
  • Buying
  • Selling
  • Search
  • Featured Listings
  • Areas
  • About Us
  • Contact
Legal
  • Privacy
  • Terms
  • DMCA
  • Accessibility
  • Fair Housing
Account
  • Dashboard
  • Logout
  • Login
Salt Shore Team - Footer Logo
©2026 Signature Premier Properties. All rights reserved.
Website built by CloseHack.
OneKey MLS

IDX information is provided exclusively for personal, non-commercial use, and may not be used for any purpose other than to identify prospective properties consumers may be interested in purchasing. Information is deemed reliable but not guaranteed.

Back

Listings in Margaretville, NY

Salt Shore Team Signature Premier Properties

Get more information about Margaretville

Margaretville Listings Market Stats Subdivisions Zip Codes Neighborhood FAQs Nearby

Houses in Margaretville, NY

homeMore houses
37350 State Highway 28
$224,000
KEY1038731
For Sale
37350 State Highway 28 Margaretville, NY 12455
3 Beds bathtub 1.5 Baths straighten 1365 sq ft
822 Burton Hill Road
$995,000
KEY1012448
For Sale
822 Burton Hill Road Margaretville, NY 12455
3 Beds bathtub 3 Baths straighten 3559 sq ft
352 Galli Curci
$3,250,000
KEY909245
For Sale
352 Galli Curci Margaretville, NY 12455
7 Beds bathtub 6 Baths straighten 8276 sq ft

Lots & Land in Margaretville, NY

crop_landscapeMore land
Hubbell Hill Road
$350,000
KEY1027019
For Sale
Hubbell Hill Road Margaretville, NY 12455

MARKET SNAPSHOT

The Market at a Glance

How homes have been selling here over the last 90 days.

home_work New This Week 0
Went Under Contract 0
trending_down Price Reductions 0
payments Median Sale Price $167,500 —
square_foot Price per Sq Ft —
schedule Avg Days on Market 472
sell Homes Sold 1
percent Sale-to-List Ratio 80.0%
inventory_2 Months of Inventory 17.7

Price & Sales History

Market data reflects closed sales over the last 90 days and is provided for informational purposes.

Salt Shore Team Signature Premier Properties (631) 306-4663 ryan@rezinas.com

Zip Codes

BROWSE BY ZIP

Browse listings by postal code in this area.

068072 homes for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$629 sales in the last 90 days
068111 home for saleMedian sale$490KPer sq ft$6247 sales in the last 90 days
068122 homes for saleMedian sale$600KPer sq ft$633 sales in the last 90 days
068308 homes for saleMedian sale$1.2MPer sq ft$6733 sales in the last 90 days
068312 homes for saleMedian sale$1.9MPer sq ft$2920 sales in the last 90 days
069021 home for saleMedian sale$310KPer sq ft$62118 sales in the last 90 days
069034 homes for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$539 sales in the last 90 days
074501 home for saleMedian sale$760KPer sq ft$4921 sale in the last 90 days
076771 home for saleMedian sale$1.3MPer sq ft$62
078271 home for saleMedian sale$190KPer sq ft$1091 sale in the last 90 days
086111 home for saleMedian sale$203KPer sq ft$85413 sales in the last 90 days
088161 home for saleMedian sale$570KPer sq ft$30568 sales in the last 90 days
View All Zip Codes
Get Alerts Advanced Search
  • Grid
  • Map
  • List
37350 State Highway 28 For Sale
$224,000
37350 State Highway 28Margaretville, NY 12455
  • 3 bd
  • 1.5 ba
  • 1365 sqft
  • Built 1940
  • KEY1038731
822 Burton Hill Road For Sale
$995,000
822 Burton Hill RoadMargaretville, NY 12455
  • 3 bd
  • 3 ba
  • 3559 sqft
  • Built 1983
  • KEY1012448
352 Galli Curci For Sale
$3,250,000
352 Galli CurciMargaretville, NY 12455
  • 7 bd
  • 6 ba
  • 8276 sqft
  • Built 1926
  • KEY909245
3
Nearby Cities
All Cities
  • Arkville1.8 mi4 Listings
  • Andes9.3 mi2 Listings
  • Bovina Center10 mi3 Listings
  • Livingston Manor19 mi64 Listings
  • Claryville16 mi7 Listings
  • Delhi17 mi8 Listings
  • Prattsville16 mi4 Listings
  • Hamden17 mi6 Listings
  • Roscoe21 mi40 Listings
  • Bloomville17 mi4 Listings
  • Parksville20 mi22 Listings
  • Downsville18 mi6 Listings
Similar Searches
  • For Sale in Margaretville
  • Rentals in Margaretville
  • Houses in Margaretville
  • Condos & Apartments in Margaretville
  • Townhouses & Duplexes in Margaretville
  • Lots & Land in Margaretville
  • Farms & Ranches in Margaretville
Featured Areas
All Areas
  • East Setauket74 Listings
  • Patchogue64 Listings
  • Sayville59 Listings
  • Stony Brook54 Listings
  • Oakdale31 Listings
  • Bellport23 Listings
  • Bayport18 Listings
  • Blue Point15 Listings
Featured Searches
Advanced Search
  • $200k to $300k Homes
  • $300k to $400k Homes
  • $400k to $500k Homes
  • Acreage
  • Commercial Properties
  • Farms & Ranches
  • Golf Course Homes
  • Homes Listed this Week
  • Homes with 2+ Beds
  • Homes with Pools
  • Large Houses (2k+ sqft)
  • Luxury Condos ($400k+)
  • Multi-Family Homes
  • New Construction
  • Oceanfront Condos
  • Rentals Under $2k
  • Rentals with Pets
  • Under $200k Homes
  • Under $250k Homes
  • Water View Homes
  • Water View Homes
Popular Cities
All Cities
  • Flushing810 Listings
  • Bronx698 Listings
  • Brooklyn509 Listings
  • Poughkeepsie286 Listings
  • Middletown277 Listings
  • Monroe276 Listings
  • Newburgh267 Listings
  • Jamaica263 Listings
  • Yonkers225 Listings
  • White Plains213 Listings
Popular Subdivisions
All Subdivisions
  • Heritage4 Listings
  • Homestead Village4 Listings
  • Harvest Ridge3 Listings
  • The Colony2 Listings
  • Riverwalk2 Listings
  • Fairways2 Listings
  • The Hollows1 Listings
  • Seasons1 Listings
  • Woodland Estates1 Listings
Popular Zip Codes
All Zips
  • Homes in 212231 Listings
  • Homes in 11354419 Listings
  • Homes in 190501 Listings
  • Homes in 086111 Listings
  • Homes in 12550274 Listings
  • Homes in 10950269 Listings
  • Homes in 11746246 Listings
  • Homes in 11355239 Listings
  • Homes in 088161 Listings
  • Homes in 11758202 Listings
Recent Articles
All Articles
  • How Long Does It Take to Sell a House in Oakdale, New York? Insights from Ryan Rezinas and the Salt Shore Team
  • Oakdale Downsizing Success: Your Guide to Right-Sizing Your Home with Ryan Rezinas and the Salt Shore Team
  • Oakdale, NY Homeowners: Should You Sell Your House Now or Wait? Local Market Insights from Ryan Rezinas and Salt Shore Team
  • Discover Oakdale’s Top Real Estate Agent: Ryan Rezinas and the Salt Shore Team’s Local Expertise
  • How Long Does It Really Take to Sell a House in Blue Point, New York? A Local Guide by Ryan Rezinas
  • From Spacious to Simplified: Expert Tips for Downsizing My Home in Blue Point, New York with Ryan Rezinas and Salt Shore Team
  • Blue Point Homeowners: Should I Sell My House Now or Wait? Expert Advice from Ryan Rezinas at Salt Shore Team
  • Blue Point Real Estate Excellence: Why Ryan Rezinas Is the Top Real Estate Agent in Blue Point, New York
  • How Quickly Can You Sell a House in Bayport, New York? Insights From Salt Shore Team
  • A Local Expert’s Guide to Downsizing Your Home in Bayport, New York with Ryan Rezinas and the Salt Shore Team

City Guide

About Margaretville

Real Estate & Housing

Neighborhoods

Lifestyle in Margaretville

Schools & Education

Getting Around

Parks & Recreation

About Margaretville

Frequently asked questions

Where do we start?

Start with mortgage pre-approval — it tells you what you can spend before you fall in love with a home. From there, we'll help you find neighborhoods that fit how you actually live, and walk you through every step of the purchase.

How long does it take to sell?

Timelines depend on the market, your price, and your home's condition. Right now, most well-priced homes sell in 30 to 60 days. We'll put together a plan that makes your property stand out and gets it in front of serious buyers.

What costs should I anticipate?

Buyers usually pay closing costs — lender fees, title insurance, inspections — roughly 2 to 5 percent of the purchase price. Sellers handle agent commissions and any repairs you agree to. We walk through every cost up front, so there are no surprises at closing.

Should I buy or sell first?

It depends on your finances and what the market looks like. Bridge loans and contingent offers each work in different situations. We'll talk through the trade-offs so you can move forward with a plan that makes sense for you.

Why work with us?

We know these neighborhoods because we live here. Every agent on our team works in the community they serve, so the advice you get goes deeper than what a spreadsheet can tell you. We use technology to keep things clear and simple. The result? A smooth experience from your first search to the day you get the keys.

Still have questions about Margaretville?

Get in touch
  • Local Guide
  • Cities

Explore the area

Nearby cities

Andes, NY2 homes for saleMedian$160,000Days on market464Per sq ft$378
Arkville, NY4 homes for sale
Bloomville, NY4 homes for sale
Boiceville, NY3 homes for saleMedian$500,000Days on market28Per sq ft$260
Bovina Center, NY3 homes for sale
Claryville, NY7 homes for saleMedian$395,000Days on market37
Delhi, NY8 homes for saleMedian$278,000+58.9%Days on market176Per sq ft$360
Downsville, NY6 homes for sale
Fallsburg, NY28 homes for saleMedian$447,500+27.9%Days on market183Per sq ft$15
Gilboa, NY5 homes for saleMedian$435,000Days on market154Per sq ft$114
Grahamsville, NY16 homes for saleMedian$215,000Days on market198Per sq ft$157
Hamden, NY6 homes for saleMedian$368,000+41.9%Days on market249Per sq ft$266
Liberty, NY64 homes for saleMedian$269,000+2.9%Days on market90Per sq ft$83
Livingston Manor, NY64 homes for saleMedian$374,000Days on market178Per sq ft$83
Loch Sheldrake, NY10 homes for saleMedian$150,000Days on market99
Mount Tremper, NY2 homes for saleMedian$820,000Days on market28Per sq ft$366
Neversink, NY8 homes for saleMedian$602,000+150.3%Days on market186Per sq ft$335
Parksville, NY22 homes for saleMedian$465,250Days on market139Per sq ft$213
Phoenicia, NY2 homes for saleMedian$425,000Days on market221Per sq ft$407
Prattsville, NY4 homes for saleMedian$372,000Days on market219Per sq ft$246
Roscoe, NY40 homes for saleMedian$637,000Days on market204Per sq ft$261
Walton, NY9 homes for saleMedian$209,350−11.9%Days on market35Per sq ft$117
Windham, NY17 homes for saleMedian$1,077,500+60.0%Days on market109Per sq ft$211
Woodbourne, NY18 homes for saleMedian$346,000Days on market428Per sq ft$73
24